A systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative research concerning venue-based exercise interventions for people with stroke in the UK has just been published in the journal ‘Physiotherapy’. The available evidence base analysed found that the ARNI fares better than Exercise Referral Schemes in terms of survivors making important improvements in activities of daily life (ADL). including eating, dressing and household tasks. ARNI has been found to improve physical function and mobility and importantly, is non-ambulant people inclusive.
This synthesis by Sheffield-Hallam University researchers Rachel E Young (Senior Lecturer in Physiotherapy & Specialist Neurological Physiotherapist), Dr David Broom (Reader of Physical Activity and Health), Professor Karen Sage (Professor for Allied Health Professions), Kay Crossland (Clinical Specialist Physiotherapist) and Dr Christine Smith (Deputy Head, Department of Allied Health Professions) makes the salient point that exercise following stroke leads to reduced physiological risk factors, improved physical function and mobility.
It is reasonably well-known that in general, exercise after stroke participation is known to be associated with significant improvements in quality of life. Data relating to the effects of exercise following stroke suggests that participants perceive improvements in physical function, participation and psychosocial wellbeing.
But it may be less well-known that engagement with exercise amongst the UK stroke population does not meet published recommendations and that exercise referral participants advised to go to gyms report feeling intimidated in the traditional gym environment. Moreover, that long-term adherence to exercise referral programmes is less than 50%. This is not good at all.
ARNI Approach on the other hand, is known for primarily being a one to one approach with the point that all stroke survivors are different and often require highly customised rehab/exercise teaching/support in their own homes even to be able to get out and re-join the community. Further, some survivors have no desire to go to gyms or involve themselves in groups.
But ARNI does run also a number of small groups around the UK, eg. ARNI Port Talbot, Wales – BBC News Report from 2015.
Please read also this prior ARNI blog article: Exercise After Stroke: Everything You Need To Know.
The ARNI group work follows a similar kind of methodology/protocol that one to one the intensive type of exercise/rehab training that ARNI is well-known for. Therefore ARNI group training is highly adaptable, hard work (makes you sweat!) and highly differentiated throughout sessions rather than a ‘one size fits all’ approach (as noted by the last bullet point, below).
This systematic review compares studies of ARNI groups and UK exercise referral schemes. Of all studies, one concerning ARNI had the greatest age-range: 19-84.
Rachel Young reflects (to me) on the benefits of ARNI Approach from the data she sees:
- Participants on ARNI programmes feel challenged to push the boundaries of their recovery and experiment with new activities.
- The ARNI programme offers a de-medicalised experience and facilitates people with stroke to gain confidence in their local communities and public venues.
- ARNI exercises are associated with improved physical function and mobility.
- The ARNI intervention is inclusive to non-ambulant people with stroke, who report equal benefit and improved quality of life associated with the programme to their ambulant peers.
- The ARNI approach incorporates a peer leadership model which fostered an atmosphere of group support and encouragement.
- The ARNI model integrates group exercise with individualised goals and activities to capture the benefits of peer support with an individualised programme.
As noted in the second sentence of this blog, the impact of exercise upon Activities of Daily Living (ADL) was mixed when scrutinising data from those doing Exercise on Referral (ERS) schemes, with participants from two of the studies suggesting that they did not experience improved performance in ADLs. In contrast, participants who had engaged with the ARNI programmes identified specific improvements in ADLs including eating, dressing and household tasks.
Exercise referral schemes (ERS) were perceived as a substitute for physiotherapy. In contrast, participants from the Norris et al (2010) study concerning ARNI stated that they had felt “mollycoddled in hospital” and that the ARNI programme was the opposite to “half-baked physiotherapy.”
Analytical theme 1: “Training principles as a foundation for programme design.”
The ARNI Training principles as a foundation for programme design were found to be a significant factor:
The synthesis found that all participants on ARNI programmes experimented with attempting new things, and tasks they thought they could not do. Participation in the ARNI programme had re-introduced experimentation which is likely to have increased confidence. For example: “I’m finding I can stand up now without having to push myself up on my hands. I’m doing that more often. I’ve even tried a couple of times from the settee, which is low down, and I’ve done it.”
The synthesis also found the the ARNI training described as a physical challenge both in its intensity but also the activities undertaken in the programme. For example: “Challenging, I found it was very challenging, just the first day when we had to sort of actually walk on a mat without a stick…I felt that was really challenging…but also encouraging, to do more than I thought I could.
In some contrast, in relation to Exercise Referral Scheme, the synthesis found that some participants viewed the focus of gyms to be on fitness rather than rehabilitation and whatever they did in the gym would not further their functional ability. For example: “Once they’ve assessed you, you’ve got this key you put in the machine, it tells you how long you’ve got to do and everything. With a computer you don’t need an instructor”
Analytical theme 2: “I’m not just a stroke patient anymore”
The synthesis found there was a sentiment that the individuals’ capacity had been artificially limited and that was now being tested by the ARNI Programme.
Implicit in many of the comments taking part in the ARNI Programmes was the idea that the individual had been challenged to reconceive their own possibilities. For example: “Whatever you do don’t medicalise it .. I think one of the key benefits of this is that it’s not another bloody appointment. You know it’s not the hospital… it’s also a community facility .. it introduces you and makes other things accessible”
A commonality of all approaches in rehab/exercise after stroke was revealed by the synthesis too: Post-stroke self was portrayed as fragile. Lack of confidence and purpose and perceptions of how people viewed them post-stroke made it easy for participants to retreat into “safe environments”. For example: “The fact that I could contribute and I still had something to give, I wouldn’t say to society. But I wasn’t just a has-been. When you do come home from having stroke you do feel that you are a has-been”.
This does make the requirement for the stroke survivor to ‘take back control’ and become as autonomous as possible in his or her ADLs, as key to progression and ‘beating/managing’ the effects of stroke.
When it is borne in mind that these group studies show data from just 6 to 12 one hour sessions, the heightened ARNI training effects of intensive one to one retraining with a exercise professional can be possibly be surmised… and many are shown here in ARNI Rehab Testimonials
A sentence needs to be highlighted from the conclusion of this synthesis: ‘Rehabilitation services need to collaborate with exercise providers to facilitate a positive transition towards long term exercise participation.’
————————————-
Tom says: ‘This is exactly so. Healthcare professionals would like there to be a seamless provision of support and ideally, rehab plus exercise. But public often find out upon discharge that the wait for a community OT or physio to come and help can be up to 12 weeks (or more). The therapy may or may not be beneficial enough or continue long enough. Some last for 6 sessions (of 45 minutes or so). The survivor most usually isn’t taught how to help themselves’.
‘Group classes, if they exist for stroke, are extremely patchy around the UK and often the survivor is in no fit state at all to attend. Often the group classes are not ‘retraining focused’. If they are, they’re at best run by stretched physiotherapists who are not exercise professionals… although some are and of course there is natural cross-over’.
‘So the survivor is left with, if they want to rehabilitate optimally, attending a really good physiotherapy clinic once a week – go to somewhere like Hobbs Rehabilitation or PhysioFunction which are both great. Or they can ask for for an ARNI Instructor to come to their house weekly or daily. ARNI is very affordable and has a 20 year history of rehab/reintegration-to-lifestyles successes.
An outstanding free (but by its nature, quite booked up) Queen Square Upper Limb Clinic set up by Professor Nick Ward (see prior blog page for interview). Rehab services like Professor Ward’s Institute of Neurology have recognised this synthesis’ conclusion above a long time ago (at least 12 years now), and have made strenuous efforts to work with/teach exercise & rehab trainers about neurorehabilitation and the potential of the brain to adapt via repetitive activities. And how to steer rehab re-training efforts optimally.’
Tom has consistently noted that Neuro-services and experts in Neurorehabilitation, working hand in hand with exercise professionals (as far as their very limited time can allow) to provide support/learning for that next ‘rung’ (the rehab/exercise professionals) who CAN offer long term rehab, is THE key.
Synthesis:
Young, R.E., Broom, D., Sage, K., Crossland, K., Smith, C. (2021) Experiences of venue-based exercise interventions for people with stroke in the UK: a systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative research. Physiotherapy, 110:5-14. Read here
Thomas Eldred (Verified Purchase) – (USA)
My husband had a stroke 2 years ago. He works hard every day to rehab, and Tom Balchin’s book and videos are so helpful. My husband, also named Tom, has not learned how to get up off the floor, however, or to get down. He never felt confident practicing that and in all the PT he did, no-one ever suggested it. Tom is very strong and except for his first week at home from hospital, he had not fallen until last week. Now he is willing to learn the technique, but we cannot go to PT due to Corona Virus, and I am not confident to do it without help. However, we are learning the technique, and I am practicing it, and at least if he falls again, we will have a strategy! I really thought he would be able to get up if he fell, but he couldn’t. Thank God for our neighbor! We are really also grateful to Tom Balchin for dedicating himself to helping stroke survivors. My husband, Tom, is 75 years old, a retired police officer and a determined man, but we needed Tom’s DVDs to help with rehab at home. Thank you.
Elvira Oravecz Péter (Verified Purchase) – (Hungary)
Petr Pokorny (Verified Purchase) –
These videos are such good guidelines for upper limb rehabilitation. I watched the upper limb volume (along with the volume 5) several times and keep coming back to it in order to remember the techniques as well as for getting further inspiration. I always find something new in it. One thing is to understand the material and another one is to successfully apply these methods to a client who had a stroke. These functional stretching techniques differ so much from traditional physiotherapy and are much more logic within this holistic concept. Moreover, they work.
Enikő (Verified Purchase ) –
All DVDs are very important to us for my husband, every move is very precious every minute, thanks for the help, we work every day, we learn. We want good health and good luck Enikő and Ernő
Tim Webster (Verified Purchase) –
Full of practical tips, drills and ideas, “THE SUCCESSFUL STROKE SURVIVOR” videos are an excellent resource for stroke survivors.
Suzie (Verified Purchase) –
I definitely recommend these dvds, beautifully presented and easy to follow and very inspirational. I use them now in addition to my private physio to help in my recovery, only wish they were available earlier. Lots of training strategies and exercises developed by Tom, a true expert and stroke survivor. Don’t hesitate buy the complete set.
Nicole Wright (Verified Purchase) –
I am an ARNI instructor in training and I am finding these videos essential in helping me become a knowledgeable, effective and inspired trainer. I purchased the complete set, along with Dr Balchin’s Stroke Survivor book and I refer to them on a daily basis and I know they will continue to be an indispensable tool in my development. Each technique is clearly explained and demonstrated by Tom and the great thing is that you can pause at any point to try it yourself, or listen back to something. If you are a carer, friend or family member, wanting to help a loved one who has had a stroke then these DVDs are a must.
Mark Bowra MBE (Verified Purchase) –(UK)
As a former Royal Marine, these exercises have been paramount in improving the functional use of both my arm and hand. I would wholly recommend ‘DVD Volume 5’ to anyone who wishes to improve their condition, following a stroke.
Russ Kennedy (Verified Purchase) – (USA)
It’s my pleasure to recommend the Stroke Solutions DVD. I purchased the book, The Successful Stroke Survivor, about five years ago but found that I needed to be shown how to do certain exercises. Since I have obtained the affordable and worthwhile DVD, I continually refer to it. I wish that you had been able to make it available sooner. Many thanks. Russ Kennedy PhD, MBA, MPH
Justin Smallwood (Verified Purchase) –(UK)
Don’t muck about umming and aahing! Just get the lot! Tom will then help get you going. Tom is really easy to listen to; clear and thoughtful. Then, when he gets down to it, he shows you how it’s done. Tom is strong and agile but his fluent movement is as a result of hard work. If you get half as good as Tom, you’ve gone a long way. The DVDs are, in my view, essential viewing for stroke survivors, their family and friends and those training to become rehab trainers.
Peter Corfield (Verified Purchase) –(France)
I had an AVM stroke 1st June 2010.We were in France. My wife found me on the floor having returned from an art experience there was no way of telling how long I had been there. Maybe 4/5 hours or longer a helicopter was called from Dijon I was flown to a hospital in a coma. Missed out on the view. They did an emergency craniotomy to repair the vein that had burst .I was put in an induced coma for about 2 and a half weeks. When I awoke I was hemiplegic left side. Enough about me. These DVDs are so Amazing I can’t tell you how good they are in words try them yourself. I may even do some of the exercises as my you tube stroke blog when I have enough time in the day . You may have seen me armchair gardening filling and emptying the dishwasher fetching the wood. Everyday life can be achieved after stroke and I owe it all to Dr. Tom Balchin and Arni Institute. Buy the DVDs they are Awesome.
Nick Cole (Verified Purchase) –(UK)
The experience of stroke can be totally bewildering for the patient and their partners/loved ones. One moment getting on with your life fine and the next – BAM! – you’re flat on your back in a hospital bed with only half of your body working properly! Thankfully, a friend with MS put my wife in touch with Tom Balchin (way back in 2005) and since that time I’ve had two ARNI Instructors.
Finally, all his knowledge is distilled into a set of DVDs. They’re pure gold dust, refined over many years experience working with stroke survivors of all ages. I’m working through the exercises in the DVDs and they still form the basis of my twice-weekly physiotherapy and self-rehab programme.
Louis Rowson (Verified Purchase) –(UK)
Found the DVDs very inspirational, I have had a lot of help from the wonderful therapists in North Devon, but need now to move on and I believe Tom’s DVDs will help me. My initial prognosis left me wheelchair bound, but with determination and support I can now walk with support, my left hand is still of very little use but I have been given fresh motivation by the DVDs.
Elizabeth Wallfisch (Verified Purchase) – (UK)
These DVDs are beautifully and compassionately presented by Dr Tom Balchin and his team! Every move, exercise, strategy is clearly described and demonstrated, with many repetitions of the complexities of some of the coping strategies and functional training techniques and drills. I recommend these to every stroke survivor and their families, and carers. As an adjunct to ‘The Successful Stroke Survivor’ the DVDs give strong visual and aural cues to the descriptions in the book. This actually makes the learning of, and thus the effective implementation of the strategies, much more accessible.
Gary Sacheck (Verified Purchase) – (USA)
I am a stroke survivor and agree with the statement that, “knowledge is power” and this video plus all those that accompany this in Tom’s collection deliver that specific knowledge that a stroke survivor needs. This video like all in the collection inspire and provide the variety and “make it fun & interesting” style in your exercises to help you keep your rehab progressing.
Owen Thomas (Verified Purchase) –(UK)
Very informative and helpful: clear and concise instructions with great attention to detail on technique! Thank you!